Ben Child: Peter Jackson, in resurrecting Legolas and reshuffling other roles, appears to be taking Game of Thrones-esque liberties with his source material
What started out as cheap, populist entertainment in comic book form has turned into an endless and insanely expensive parade of sexist, semi-fascist bores, says Joe Queenan
Peter Bradshaw: Julie Maroh, as author of its source novel, has unique credentials to comment, but for what it's worth I felt the film's descent into agony and tears took it clear of titillation