There is no doubt that Oscar and Lucinda has won over readers and critics alike, but could their love of the novel have blinded them to its lack of subtlety and implausible storyline?
Leader: All sorts of people are qualified to judge books these days. Former cabinet minister Michael Portillo was yesterday named as the next chair of the Man Booker panel, while pop star Lily Allen will help judge the Orange
Reading this year's Booker longlist was such an enjoyable experience that I've decided to read through all the previous winners, from 1969 onwards. First up, PH Newby's Something To Answer For
Jason Cowley: Last week, the chairman of the Booker Prize judges complained about the nepotistic world of book reviews. But he missed a far greater problem besetting the modern publishing industry.