
That's all for today!
Thank you to Kathryn for giving us so much of her time, and to everyone who has posted a question. Our reading group theme for July will be put to a vote tomorrow - check in then!
Murdomania says:
The 10-year-old me played the Artful Dodger in a reprise of Oliver! in a school musical in the late 1970s: Lionel Bart got a bit grumpy about this and we had to ditch the songs (so The Beatles’ ‘Yesterday’ replaced ‘Where is Love?’ etc.) Which of Dickens’ other works do you think merit a musical makeover?
Morse1969 asks:
How are we to reconcile the empathy that Dickens amply demonstrates for the desperate and the downtrodden in Victorian England with his own behaviour? His treatment of his wife, once his head was turned by the teenage Nelly Ternan - in itself, very dubious - was utterly merciless, separating the children from her and at one point pondering whether to commit her to an asylum. Was he simply a sociopath, for whom others were merely fodder for his pen? Was he ironically more like Skimpole than he would have liked to admit? Is it possible, in 2020, to read his novels without a huge sense of disquiet, a feeling that he cheated us all along?
Nom_DePlume adds:
This is such a good question. I’ve also read that he helped impoverished women get out of a life of prostitution while simultaneously believing it was acceptable to take advantage of their services (whether he did himself or not).
jamesmery asks:
What’s your favorite film/series adaptation of a Dickens novel?...mine, Little Dorrit with Claire Foy, and an all around terrific cast...
iandibrenda has another:
Is there a connection between Dickens’ metaphor of capitalism as “dustheap” and Dostoyevsky’s use of “antheap” as an analogy for society?
Updated
iandibrenda says:
Dickens gets Wegg to read Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire. Did Dickens foresee this happening to the British Empire or is it purely an internal device to foreshadow the fate of the Boffins?
Updated
nycsrs asks:
Which character in the novel is the Mutual Friend of the title? The book seems to be, in part, about loyalty, but did Dickens consider alternate titles, and what is the significance of his final choice?
deadgod has a question unrelated to Dickens:
You teach “biographical studies”. What’s your favorite, your desert-island one-and-one-only-survived-the-shipwreck, biography? (My favorite is Peter Brown’s Augustine of Hippo. I guess it’s a promotion-of-one-of-my-favorite-books pseudo-question, ha ha ha.)
Rembetis has a three questions:
I find the character Jenny Wren in Our Mutual Friend fascinating. Dickens often based his characters on people he knew. Was Jenny Wren based on a real person?
Some of the passages in ‘Our Mutual Friend’ between Bella Wilfer and her father are absolutely cringe inducing to modern eyes. Would they have been viewed so when the book was first released?
Biographers tend to the view that Dickens died at the age of 58 because he was burned out from his constant frenetic energy, not least during his frequent Reading Tours and his frenzied performance of ‘Sykes and Nancy’. However, he had been hypocritically leading a double life in his last 12 years with his mistress Nelly Ternan. Wouldn’t the real fear of being publicly discovered and exposed, the duplicity of maintaining a double life for so long with ‘fake identities’, and the constant stress of keeping those lives entirely separate, have had a devastating effect on his physical and mental health?
'I'm not sure we can ever fully reconcile Dickens' empathy for the downtrodden in Victorian England with his cruel treatment of his wife'
klikkonthis says:
Ever since I’ve learned more about Dickens’ divorce of his wife, and his attempts to have her committed, and to keep her children away from her, I’ve found I enjoy his books far less. How do you reconcile the talented author, and social commentator/campaigner with this darker side?
robertrudolph asks:
Do you think that Dickens relied on coincidence to tie up his huge plots, or that this was part of his sense of the world?
drragon asks:
How do you think Edwin Drood should end?
(If you don’t understand this question, Edwin Drood was Dickens’ final novel, which was left unfinished when he died in 1870. A few writers have attempted to finish it.)
McScootikins says:
Oliver Twist struck me as antisemitic in a number of its more descriptive passages, however my university lecturer assured me Dickens wasn’t an antisemite, just a reflection of his era. He’s a fascinating writer, but do you see Dickens’ creations such as Fagin as problematic in this era of “cancel culture”?
And pbendall replies:
I think the “reflection of his era” point is completely bogus. What about all the people of his time who were opposed to antisemitism? Aren’t they equally a reflection of their era?
Updated
'It can be tricky to understand what's going on when you're reading Dickens' later books for the first time'
Sidslac says:
A very new and novice Dickens reader here, only read A Tale of Two Cities and A Christmas Carol. Sometimes I don’t understand entire paragraphs in his books, I can often get the gist of it and I have enjoyed the stories so far but, I have had to use reading guides to help me. Is it because the writing style was different back in his day or am I just not really that educated on my own language?
'If Dickens was writing today he'd make bankers into his baddies'
onlyonpaper says:
If Wells’ time machine could be borrowed to bring Dickens to the present day, do you think he’d notice much difference in human relations? What do you think he’d make of the Internet and social media? If he were to write a book about the early 21st century, what, in your opinion, would the main theme or themes be and who do you think he’d base his heroes/ heroines and villains on?
Kathryn Hughes is with us now
Thank you for joining us!
NellyLawless kicks things off:
What’s your favorite biography of Dickens? Tomalin? Ackroyd?
Post your questions now!
Kathryn Hughes will join us for a webchat about Charles Dickens, the subject of this month’s reading group, on 29 June at 12pm BST.
Kathryn Hughes is the professor of life writing at the University of East Anglia, a fine literary critic and the author of several acclaimed books about eminent Victorians and Victorian life.
George Eliot, The Last Victorian won her the James Tait Black Memorial prize for biography in 1999, and The Short Life and Long Times of Mrs Beeton was longlisted for the Samuel Johnson prize in 2005. Victorians Undone: Tales of the Flesh in the Age of Decorum, an account of what it was like to live in the body of a Victorian, was described as a “dazzling experiment in life writing”.
You can get an idea of how well she writes about Dickens himself by reading this piece on Bleak House, written for the Guardian in 2011, and this longer article on A Christmas Carol, marital strife and Dickens’ relationship with his traumatic past.
We will benefit greatly from Kathryn’s expertise on Dickens and Victorians, and she’s been rereading Our Mutual Friend in order to answer specific questions about that extraordinary book.
She will be answering questions from 12pm on Monday 29 June, but please post your questions early.
Updated

This is Kathryn here again signing off. I'm sorry if I didn't get to your question. I was typing as fast as I could. I've had a lovely time and I hope you have too. Kathryn