That's all for today …
Updated
MysteryTrampNR asks:
You write eloquently of rootless characters, those orphans of history like Claudia in Moon Tiger and Eva Burden in City of the Mind. [These are characters] who, while they may live in England, live elsewhere emotionally – what you call, writing of Eva in City of the Mind, a secret, “personal elsewhere”, “an invisible point of reference, known only to you, making you different”. It is a theme that would seem to derive from your own experience growing up in Cairo …
It is a theme that draws me back to your work, because, like you, my formative years were lived in the Middle East, and that sense of displacement is something I feel acutely. I wonder if you have ever become fully reconciled to being “English” or have, in some sense, felt like an outsider here? Doris Lessing once said, “Once you have left one place, you have left them all.” Do you share that sense of rootlessness and of living out of place?
Hillgazer asks:
Are Claudia’s experiences in Moon Tiger based on any real women? My book group is meeting tonight to discuss the novel, so this online discussion is very well timed!
Also, I’ve also noticed in other books we’ve read that the main character is often a writer – and that writing and being an author are the themes underpinning the narrative. What are your thoughts on this?
MachenBach asks:
In Moon Tiger, I was struck by the recurrence of spiralled figures – the Moon Tiger coil itself, but also the asteroceras fossil, and even the individual chapters seem to spiral from the present (Claudia dying in bed) through stages of the past to those core events of the novel. As Claudia asserts: “Life has its core […] its centre.” Is this merely Claudia’s opinion, as a historian, or is it one that you share?
One of the things I most appreciated about the novel is that, despite the (presumably) formative influence of these core events on Claudia, nothing is over-explained or reductively psychologised. The answer to the question as to why Claudia is the type of person she is remains nicely nebulous. This uncertainty perhaps mirrors the argument between Claudia and Jasper, where the former asserts that “You can’t dismiss ancestry,” while Jasper believes that “I am what I make myself.”
What elements of yourself do you attribute to your “ancestry” or to your self-making?
AlfaBetta asks:
The free library at our beach had a copy of Ammonites & Leaping Fish. I grabbed it last week because I was yearning for an escape as I approach my 60th birthday, one where I learn to write a memoir. You brought up solipsism at least three times in the first chapter. Is solipsism is a risk for writers (and by extension for their readers), or does it enhance stories as well?
allworthy asks:
I came to your writing first through your children’s literature, which enthralled many children I taught. The Whispering Knights a particular favourite. Is writing for children different from adults? What are the decisions you make in determining this is a book aimed at children, even though adults enjoy them anyway. Is children’s fiction in good shape? Thanks for all the pleasure you’ve given me.
'Forty years ago, I saw everything differently'
JoannaTroha asks:
Do you feel as though your personal relationship to your characters shifts with the changes in your life and how you perceive the world? Changes in empathy, compassion and judgment, for example?
Fleur01 asks:
Have loved your writing for so many years. I reread The Road to Lichfield so often, most of the pages have detached. Why is the word “palimpsest” so important to you? It recurs so frequently.
Camaradeau asks:
Greetings from an admiring reader in Pennsylvania!
I recently finished Cleopatra’s Sister, and loved it, though Treasures in Time remains my favourite.
I am curious to know how closely you’ve worked with your translators. Do you feel particularly attached to the literature of any language other than English?
Sunshot17 asks:
Aside from her woeful and unforgivable lack of looks and charisma (in Jasper’s and Claudia’s eyes), I think Lisa clearly suffers in comparison to the chimerical, miscarried child of Tom, that she would never live up to the fantasy of the highly desired baby of the beloved, dead fiance. Do you agree?
Also, given the great love between Claudia and Gordon, do you think they would have equally adored a (secret?) baby born of incest, if they did indeed take their relationship to that extreme?
Earliest memory: under a mosquito net in Egypt
LLCoolJ_ asks:
I am a huge fan: A few years ago, in what I considered a somewhat unorthodox job interview for a hi-tech administrative job, I was asked, “Which person – living or dead – would you most like to be?” I responded, “Penelope Lively.” When I was offered the job, I turned it down because of the blank stares I received. (“No readers here,” I grumbled.)
I have three questions; please feel free to pick and choose and discard:
– So much of your work has focused on memory: what is your earliest memory?
– I recently read the lovely A House Unlocked, where you describe, among other things, a sampler of Golsoncott (with its war refugee children), stitched by your grandmother, “a fine needlewoman”. Do you do any sort of needlework?
– What is your favourite word? (I have a bet with myself that it begins with an “A”.)
Updated
PamelaButler asks:
I very much enjoyed Moon Tiger, and am grateful to Sam and the Reading group for introducing me to your work. We read Rebecca West’s Return of the Soldier before Moon Tiger. I was struck by many resemblances between West and Claudia – uncompromisingly unconventional, writer, a life of adventure, long-term lover who fathered a child she did not have a particularly good relationship with … Was West’s life an inspiration for Claudia?
Read Lively’s 2010 article for the Guardian about writing Moon Tiger here:
juliewhitney asks:
I absolutely loved Moon Tiger and have pondered over what made Claudia Claudia. How did you go about constructing her character? Claudia tells us no man measured up to Gordon until her late 20s (presumably when she met Tom), but it would seem Gordon didn’t apply the same analysis to his choice of life partner. What led you to choose Sylvia for him rather than someone who would be more of a match for Claudia, someone more likely to disrupt their “aristocracy of two”?
Magrat123 asks:
I have come to your work rather late, which is my loss! Recently I have read The Purple Swamp Hen and Making It Up; the latter was particularly helpful for this discussion as regards confabulation.
Unlike some readers, I did not dislike Claudia. She is opinionated, sometimes stridently, argumentative by nature and cannot suffer fools or people she regards as complacent or lazy. But she is a shrewd observer of people, and is never wilfully unkind or cruel.
I did enjoy the dig at academic historians who attack others who dare to write entertaining books. My question is, who are the historians who have influenced you, and who are the historians you enjoy reading?
goodyorkshirelass asks:
Hello, having read and enjoyed your novels, I had the pleasure of meeting you and Jane Gardam at the Edinburgh international book festival in, I think, 2015. A stimulating session, after which I bought Consequences. I found it completely absorbing and am about to read it again. Would you say that the impact of of one person meeting another inspire or influence your writing?
Penelope is with us now …
Updated
Join us for a webchat with Penelope Lively on 1 August
I’m delighted to say that Penelope Lively will be joining us for a live webchat on Wednesday 1 August at 4pm BST.
Lively is the author of more than 20 works of adult fiction, more than 30 works of children’s fiction and five works of non-fiction, alongside numerous reviews, radio programmes and television scripts.
Many of her books, like Moon Tiger, Heat Wave, and Oleander, Jacaranda are rightly regarded as classics. She writes with precision, compassion and eloquence about time, our place in the world, love and loss, and consciousness. Her books are profound, moving and dazzling. They’re also often highly original. Lively has an unusual ability to bend the rules of structure, voice and chronology - but never at the expense of compelling story-telling. She writes with such smooth skill that, as a reader, you are barely aware that you are enjoying something that could easily be termed “experimental”. Better still, her books can be as sharp and cheeky as they are formally daring. This is, after all, the creator of Thomas Kempe, the 17th century ghost who causes such gleeful chaos in the village of Ledsham and so enjoys persecuting priests.
Kempe’s story (The Ghost of Thomas Kempe) won the 1973 Carnegie Medal. In 1976, A Stitch In Time won the Whitbread Children’s Book Award. Her first adult novel The Road to Lichfield was published in 1977 and was shortlisted for the Man Booker Prize as was 1984’s According To Mark. Moon Tiger, of course, won in 1987. Lively is also a member of the Royal Society Of Literature, was awarded an OBE in 1989, a CBE in 2001, and made a Dame Commander Of The British Empire for services to literature in 2012.
These honours seem all the more impressive since Lively’s first book was published in 1970, when she was in her late 30s. Before that, Lively had been raising a family, had attended St Anne’s College in Oxford, and spent the first 12 years of her life in Egypt, where she was born in 1933. This upbringing famously inspired scenes in Moon Tiger, as well as evocative works of autobiography like Oleander, Jacaranda and Ammonites & Leaping Fish, not to mention some of the exquisite stories in Making It Up.
Meanwhile, here in the present, Lively continues to write and fascinate her readers. Her most recent publication is Life In The Garden, which was described here in the Guardian as “beautiful” and a “book to treasure.” We are very fortunate that its author has made time to be with us.
Penelope Lively will be answering questions on Wednesday 1 August at 4pm BST - but do please feel free to get yours in early.
Goodbye! Thank you all for your amazing interesting and challenging questions. Thank you all, and thank you for your responses to Moon Tiger.