Kirsty Wark webchat – as it happened

The broadcaster and novelist was with us to answer your questions in a live webchat – catch up on her answers on Quentin Tarantino, being shortlisted for the Bad Sex Awards, interviewing Glenn Greenwald and more
  
  

kirsty wark
Cultural polymath Kirsty Wark, soon to be answering your questions. Photograph: Graeme Robertson

That's all for today!

Thanks everyone for all your questions and to Kirsty for her great answers. Have a great afternoon!

Vee12 asks:

Hello Kirsty.

What ambitions/goals do you still have – broadcasting or otherwise – that you care to share?

User avatar for KirstyWark Guardian contributor

Brush up my French. Relearn the piano. Play better tennis. Drink better wine. Where do you want me to stop?

JezKeen asks:

A lot of people seem to think Laura Kuenssberg is a right wing attack dog, I saw her interview with Denis Healey after Tony Benn’s death and was appalled at her confrontational attitude towards a very elderly man.

Do you feel the trend for new presenters is to outpaxman Paxman ?

User avatar for KirstyWark Guardian contributor

For the record, Laura Kuenssberg is a superb journalist and certainly be caricatured as a right-wing attack dog. No presenter is trying to outpaxman Paxman, or even paxman Paxman.

Apologies to Kirsty for a transcription error: this should of course read “certainly cannot be caricatured as a right-wing attack dog”.

Updated

JayneCharters asks:

Are you able to take part in the restoration programme for McKintosh’s Art School Library? What’s your view on its future?

User avatar for KirstyWark Guardian contributor

I am so looking forward to watching the restoration of Glasgow School of Art library. And more broadly the building itself. Everybody has such affection for it, not only in Glasgow or indeed Scotland but around the world. It speaks of modernity, and beauty. And the fact that it's battered and bruised has added to people's love of it.

ID9552055 asks:

We have an well known English establishment. By all accounts, there is also an elitist, exclusive Scottish establishment. You are an intelligent person on our screens with journalistic skills, what is the impact of that Scottish establishment in Scotland itself?

User avatar for KirstyWark Guardian contributor

Don't we have a whole number of establishments? I think in Scotland the networks are more open, simply because we're a smaller country. And much more interconnected.

DavidYoung asks:

In 2007, on a panel for the Observer, you couldn’t say why the sky is blue. Why do you think scientific understanding is such a poor relation, compared to, say, the arts, for many people?

User avatar for KirstyWark Guardian contributor

Good point. I think that people need to be much more aware of the scientific world and how it affects us. It's seen as a more specialist subject than say an interest in arts and culture, but we should all be pushing ourselves to understand it more.

hobrob says:

Hi Kirsty. About a year ago you hosted an hour long studio audience debate about the motives behind the Iraq war and the word “oil” was not mentioned once. At one point you seemed to be steering the debate towards a binary choice between WMD and regime change and I found myself out of my seat shouting at the television. I’m still angry, and I need to get this off my chest! How the hell could you not even raise the possibility of oil as a motive?

User avatar for KirstyWark Guardian contributor

Sorry, of course oil was part of the story. Perhaps we should have been more explicit about it.

Debusted asks:

Hi Kirsty, what advice would you give to your 20-year-old self who’s getting ready to embark on a career in journalism in 2014?

User avatar for KirstyWark Guardian contributor

Find something and make it your specialism. It doesn't need to be politics or current affairs, it could be quantum physics or the novels of Jane Austen, but develop a passion. And write, write, write. Create a blog and promote it.

Yosserian says:

Bring back The Late Show! That looked like ramshackle fun to do? (or maybe I was just a slightly sozzled ramshackle art student at the time.)

User avatar for KirstyWark Guardian contributor

Ah! The days when the BBC put on an hour of arts and culture every night. It was a great training ground for some wonderful BBC talent. And all the better for being watched through a glass darkly sometimes.

Updated

Rufio_Renton asks:

Your career, in particular your work with Newsnight, requires a heavy amount of cynicism and scrutiny. Are you as critical of yourself as you are of others?

User avatar for KirstyWark Guardian contributor

I'd say that my work requires no cynicism, but a lot of scepticism. And yes, I am very critical of my work. I often think: why didn't I ask that question differently? Shorter, perhaps!!

Skoolyad asks:

I found your recent BBC documentary Blurred Lines to be a real eye-opener. How do you think we go about trying to “solve” the issues it highlighted?

User avatar for KirstyWark Guardian contributor

I am amazed at the response to Blurred Lines. It just keeps coming. I am so happy that teachers are using the programme in schools, and that so many people have said that it is a programme that has stayed with them. We need to keep talking about how to create a more civil society on the web.

You may think it sounds trite, but if you think that our codes of behaviour have developed over hundreds of years, and wham bam, there's a new world. If when you turned on your computer in the morning you saw something as simple as "you're entering the world wide web - please treat people you encounter here with respect", it might just make a difference.

LlivracNhoJ asks:

My approach to the Greenwald interview was the same as any other – to be rigorous, and to ask questions that people watching wanted asking.”

Weasel words. Being rigorous would have meant challenging the government, not acting as a spokeswoman for the intelligence services.

User avatar for KirstyWark Guardian contributor

Ok, I was interviewing Glenn Greenwald, not the government. And I dispute entirely that I was acting as a spokesman for the intelligence services.

On the Glenn Greenwald interview, what service would it have done anybody not to ask challenging questions?

Simbadiow asks:

Did you enjoy the Thriller dance last year? Do you think that humour fits in well with a current affairs program? (by the way, I loved the ending of that program).

[This is what this comment is referring to, in case you’re wondering]

User avatar for KirstyWark Guardian contributor

Thriller: I don't really remember doing that! Normally I like to dance in the privacy of my own home, but somebody had given me something out of a cauldron which clearly altered my mind.

Updated

clareyesno asks:

How is your second novel shaping up? And what made you want to write your first – and how did you fit it in around all your BBC work??

User avatar for KirstyWark Guardian contributor

I am excited about the second book, and have got down to work. I wanted to write fiction but had to wait until I had space to give it my best shot - I just worked and worked, becoming quite reclusive, and found it an exhilarating experience I was keen to repeat. Every hour God gave me I wrote and rewrote.

On a cab driver mistaking her for Kirsty Young

TheDogShouterer asks:

Do you think the BBC chose the right Kirsty for the Desert Island Discs gig?

User avatar for KirstyWark Guardian contributor

Kirsty Young is certainly the right woman for the job. Funnily enough the other night we had very unusually a pretty clueless London taxi driver and I am not very good on 'the knowledge' so it was a bit tense in the back of the cab. When I got out, he said: "Don't worry, I'll still listen to you on Desert Island Discs."

Updated

Kullus De Quertyman asks:

What interesting details stay in your memory from when on Newsnight you interviewed Harold Pinter?

User avatar for KirstyWark Guardian contributor

Harold Pinter was gracious and his intellect that day was all-inspiring.

"Newsnight has been firing on all cylinders"

Paul_89 asks:

Did you feel Newsnight could recover from the well-publicised scandals it has suffered recently and what place does it now hold for current affairs in today’s media?

A random sub-question too: If you had to go on a reality TV show, which one would it be?

User avatar for KirstyWark Guardian contributor

Newsnight has been firing on all cylinders.

Reality TV? The answer is: unlikely. If I had to, it's one that's not yet been designed.

flaminnora asks:

When and where do you write?

User avatar for KirstyWark Guardian contributor

I write in a sunny room at the front of the house in Glasgow, mainly. And as to when? On peaceful days, of which there are not enough.

Eesy asks:

‘afternoon, Kirsty. Do you think the BBC has lost the impartiality it was, once, famed for?

Specifically, during the Scottish independence referendum and, more recently, in reporting the “gossip” and innuendo surrounding Ed Miliband.

User avatar for KirstyWark Guardian contributor

No, I do not think the BBC has lost its impartiality.

On Tarantino: "There was absolutely no chemistry whatsoever!"

crowinthesnow asks:

I remember seeing you doing an interview with Quentin Tarantino about Kill Bill and correct me if I’m wrong but you both seemed to be very flirty with each other! There was definite chemistry. What was he like off camera?

User avatar for KirstyWark Guardian contributor

There was absolutely no chemistry whatsoever! He was friendly and charming. I wish I could have interviewed him again after Inglorious Basterds, I like that film a lot.

Updated

WoodWorker2008 asks:

Is there a 20th-century British author whom Kirsty Warks always enjoys going back to read and re-read?

User avatar for KirstyWark Guardian contributor

There are so many great authors I could pick. Rather than authors, perhaps books, and I would say that Sunset Song is one of them.

steeply asks:

Kirsty Wark the beauty within and without

How is it that you are able to let so much humanity shine through your work?

User avatar for KirstyWark Guardian contributor

Malt whisky. Preferably Arran malt.

On the Bad Sex Awards: "I am honoured to be on any shortlist along Richard Flanagan"

Jordan Knowles asks:

How does it feel to have been nominated for the prestigious Bad Sex in Fiction Award for your debut effort?

User avatar for KirstyWark Guardian contributor

I am honoured to be on any shortlist along Richard Flanagan. His Road to the Dark North was a fantastic winner of the Booker. Murakami's no slouch either.

Updated

davidcallun1957 asks:

Do you think that the Allegra Stratton interview of Shanene Thorpe on Newsnight constituted a disgrace to honest journalism? If not, then why not?

User avatar for KirstyWark Guardian contributor

It wasn't a disgrace, and Allegra is an extremely good political editor of Newsnight.

MeAlanPartridge asks:

Hi Kirsty – simple question – what’s your favourite pizza topping?

User avatar for KirstyWark Guardian contributor

Parma ham, rocket and parmesan.

maninthemoon asks:

If a government minister refuses to appear, as they often do, why do you and other interviewers take the Labour spokesman to talk? Surely if the coalition refuse to put someone up, the Labour minister should be given a free hit, otherwise you are making it easier for ministers to avoid their responsibilities. They will probably think “I won’t go, it’s awkward for me, but the interviewer will put my case over”. The BBC should use a tub of lard like they did on HIGNFY.

User avatar for KirstyWark Guardian contributor

If we are dealing with a subject over which there is a big public debate, it's important that Newsnight explores all the different arguments. But if one politician won't take part, I don't think we should automatically drop the subject, but rather find a different way of exploring it.

Melmouth asks:

Kirsty, interviewing Yvette Cooper last night you constantly referred to her as “Yvette”, I’ve noticed you don’t do this with other politicians (you don’t call IDS “Ian” for example). Is this wise? (Especially given that you have been on holiday with Labour politicians in the past.)

User avatar for KirstyWark Guardian contributor

Actually, I called the shadow home secretary 'Yvette' just once at the start of the interview, and I've probably done that across the board.

HeywoodJ asks:

Do you think journalists working for publicly-funded broadcasters should socialize with political party leaders?

User avatar for KirstyWark Guardian contributor

I think there should be no bar on who you can or cannot socialise with. If you're referring to the holiday spent with Jack and Bridget McConnell in Majorca, I had been friends with Bridget for 20 years but I have already said that perhaps it was naive not to expect some hostile reaction.

The assumption was that we would all hold the same political views, but surely you have friends with whom you agree and disagree on politics and many other things. Journalists are no different, but there is an added requirement for us to exercise a degree of caution.

"The first interview I conducted with Alex Salmond on Newsnight was a little over-combative on my part"

JWil asks:

Have you any shame about your dismissive and partisan treatment of Alex Salmond when you interviewed him for Newsnight?

User avatar for KirstyWark Guardian contributor

I think that my interviewing of Alex Salmond since he came to power has been fair, and reasonable. However, the first interview I conducted with him on Newsnight was a little over-combative on my part, and for which I apologised to him.

Updated

gbrading asks:

I was delighted to hear you narrating the Radio 4 comedy What the Future? yesterday, thus adding an air of authenticity to the programme. What made you decide to take part in a comedy which is very different from your usual work?

User avatar for KirstyWark Guardian contributor

I love narrating What the Future? It's like some kind of wacky antidote to Newsnight, and I loved taking part in Would I Lie To You and have finally made the dates work for Have I Got News For You, so it's always good to push yourself in a different direction.

simonsaint asks:

What do you think of the interesting political balance in Scotland at the moment and do you think Labour can hold of the threat of an SNP election avalanche?

User avatar for KirstyWark Guardian contributor

If you're interested in politics, Scotland is a wonderful place to be at the moment. There is a wonderful sense of public engagement, and finally the idea that the politicians have to sit up and pay attention to voters. I have absolutely no idea what will happen in the general election, but what I can say is that building on the referendum, the turnout will be higher than any recent general election.

"It's so patently obvious that Page 3 will soon be dead in the water"

RojoSeven asks:

Hi Kirsty, would you consider backing the No More Page 3 campaign (we’ll send you a t shirt!) :-)

User avatar for KirstyWark Guardian contributor

I'm not going to back a campaign - it's just so patently obvious that Page 3 will soon be dead in the water.

Updated

SchmuckOnWheels asks:

Have you ever considered an SAS survival show called Wark on the wild side?

User avatar for KirstyWark Guardian contributor

No chance of me appearing on any survival show - I like my creature comforts (and so therefore I'd never kill a rabbit either).

Updated

TheJollyRoger asks:

Kirsty,

Be honest now ...

Did you ever host a RBS IT staff Q&A session with RBS management, which was purportedly live, but which actually had pre-recorded answers?

User avatar for KirstyWark Guardian contributor

Certainly not. I have hosted an RBS Q&A session but it was live, and completely uncontrolled by RBS management. I was acting as an independent questioner.

bixentelizz asks:

What is the largest animal you think you could kill with your bare hands?

User avatar for KirstyWark Guardian contributor

I wouldn't but I could kill a rabbit. Anything bigger than that, would need the help of a heavy-duty weapon.

"Confrontation is not really Newsnight's game"

MikeWood1000 asks:

Frankly, many Newsnight episodes strike me as pretty unsatisfactory, offering not much more, and often less analysis than early evening news broadcasts such as C4 news (not that they are paragons). The lingering confrontational style often offering more heat than light. Do you agree ?? I also think that the program often uncritically accepts rather than challenging the conventional wisdom, do you think that you could all be braver?

User avatar for KirstyWark Guardian contributor

I think that Newsnight is pretty hot on analysis, and that confrontation is not really our game. I think we have to challenge, but do it in an informed and respectful way. Sometimes we get stick for interrupting, that's on occasion a fair charge. But don't you think that politicians like to filibuster whenever possible? And Newsnight is not about allowing a monologue.

Updated

TheDudeAbides Jasks:

Ah, Kirsty Wark. The thinking man’s Kate Silverton.

Does she believe that the mainstream media have to take their share of the blame for the current rise of UKIP because they muzzled reasonable debate on immigration issues for so many years?

User avatar for KirstyWark Guardian contributor

I disagree with the question. Show me any evidence that Newsnight has ever muzzled debate on immigration.

Ozoda asks:

Hi Kirsty, do you agree with Olenka Frenkiel that ageist sexism is an issue at the BBC and if so, what can be done?

User avatar for KirstyWark Guardian contributor

I think the BBC has stated very publicly that it is mindful of ageism and sexism, and it's up to all of us who work in the BBC to keep them to their word. I have no doubt that decisions have been made in the past for unacceptable reasons.

On Greenwald and Snowden: "It is not my job to give an opinion"

Slapchips asks:

Do you have regrets about your approach to the Glen Greenwald interview?

User avatar for KirstyWark Guardian contributor

Let's turn to Greenwald and Snowden now - I note there's a number of questions on the subject.

My opinion of the Snowden revelations are of absolutely no consequence and indeed it is not my job to give an opinion. My approach to the Greenwald interview was the same as any other - to be rigorous, and to ask questions that people watching wanted asking. There was a particular point at issue here: whether information in Glenn Greenwald's possession which was potentially dangerous to the lives of people in the field, information which Edward Snowden was resolute would not be revealed, was in any way vulnerable.

As an aside, I'm just back from interviewing young people in Berlin for a Newsnight special program last week, and it was interesting that Edward Snowden is, as they say, big in Berlin, as so many people in the former GDR suffered the intrusion and war of the Stasi. So they are very in tune with privacy issues.

Updated

CalcioZucchini asks:

1. Have you ever finished an interview feeling completely spent and empty by the interviewee, even to the point of questioning yourself and why you would want to continue to do this job ?

2. On the flip side - have you ever finished an interview feeling more *energetic and more *excited about your own possibilities as an interviewer or as a writer?

(*exclude the feeling of completing a tricky interview that was successful – an interview where you finished and felt that person had just given you an extra step in your stride for the day.)

User avatar for KirstyWark Guardian contributor

I have been very privileged to do a whole variety of interviews, not least I have raced back from Oxford this morning where I interviewed Philip Pullman about the theatrical interpretation of his Grimm fairy tales. It was so inspirational to meet him and also to catch sight of his very first handwritten version of His Dark Materials.

As to having an extra step in my stride, it is exhilarating when you think you've done a good job. I often think I could have done better but when I interviewed Philip Roth at his home in Connecticut I think I got the best out of him, and the revelation that he was never going to leave America again.

PlanetNat asks:

Hi Kirsty, during the Referendum coverage on BBC many of us noticed the anti-Yes bias. This has been documented in the research conducted by Dr John Robertson at University West of Scotland.

Just wondering, were you aware of your own personal bias or did you just get caught up in the culture of the BBC?

User avatar for KirstyWark Guardian contributor

Great to be at the Guardian! Alex Salmond has talked about the BBC being the state broadcaster - can I say as far as Newsnight is concerned I dispute that completely. We were all fascinated by the developments during the campaign and although of course I voted, it was important to examine all the arguments. That's what we do at the BBC.

Kirsty is with us now

Here she is in the Guardian offices. She will start answering your questions very shortly.

Post your questions for Kirsty Wark

Writing a novel has become almost de rigeur for the BBC’s current affairs presenters, though not always with complete success. According to Guardian critics, James Naughtie left the reader “disoriented and decidedly unthrilled”, while Andrew Marr’s recent satire was “stuffed with cliche and wincingly poor characterisation.”

It’s up to Kirsty Wark then to spare Auntie’s blushes. The presenter, who has ably hopped between political and cultural analysis on Newsnight for over 20 years, saw her first novel published earlier this year, The Legacy of Elizabeth Pringle. While it may have been nominated for 2014’s Bad Sex award, it was widely praised – “something of great worth and beauty gleams through the narrative and haunts the reader with its imaginative truth,” wrote Stevie Davies in the Guardian.

With work on her second novel begun – and a career full of hard-hitting encounters with everyone from Margaret Thatcher to Tony Blair, Woody Allen and Toni Morrison – she’ll be answering your questions in a live webchat on Wednesday 14 November from 1-2pm GMT. Post yours in the comments below, and she’ll answer as many as possible.

 

Leave a Comment

Required fields are marked *

*

*